1 March 2026

"Hungering for Mystery" (sermon)

Two River Pastoral Charge
Sunday March 1, 2026 – 2nd Sunday in Lent
Scripture Reading:  John 3:1-17



Let me begin with a story.  Last summer, at VBS – Vacation Bible School – our theme was water.  We had activities and experiments all involving water.  We had a lifeguard for the afternoon and spent a couple of hours down at the wharf.  And we read some stories from the bible involving water.  We read the story about how Moses parted the waters of the Red Sea so that the people could cross safely to the other side.  We read the story about how Jesus calmed the storm on the Sea of Galilee, and then the story about how Jesus and Peter were able to walk on water.  And we read the story of Jesus’s baptism.

When we read the story of Jesus’s baptism, we also talked about what is baptism.  Some of the VBS participants had seen a baptism, but others hadn’t, so then we took a life-sized baby doll – about the size and weight of a 6-month old baby – thank you, Elizabeth, for letting us use your baby doll – and we did a baptism right there in the sanctuary at Long Reach, talking about what we were doing each step of the way, and why.

At the end, when the kids were heading back out to the River Room, a couple of the older girls stayed behind and came up to me and said, “We still don’t get it.  How does the water do anything?  We don’t understand.”

And I was honest with them.  I told them that I don’t really understand it either.  How can a splash of water change a person’s life?  How can marking someone’s forehead with the sign of the cross clothe them in Christ?  How can this strange ritual that we do convey to us the love of the Creator of the Universe?

Like my questioners, I don’t truly understand how baptism works, but I trust that it does.  I trust that through the words and the water, God tells us, “I love you,” and that the Holy Spirit begins the process of transforming our lives.

In the end, though, baptism remains somewhat of a mystery.  In fact – you folks know that I’m a bit of a word nerd, and our word sacraments comes to us from Latin – sacramentum.  If we were to look for the Greek equivalent word, we would discover the word mysterion.  Our word “sacrament” is very closely related to our word “mystery.”

Let me take a bit of a detour here, because I also love reading mystery novels.  I love following the plot as it unfolds; I love trying to connect the clues before the fictional detective does; and I love the contract that mystery authors have with their readers that the good will prevail, and there won’t be any unresolved plot lines.

But the mystery that we are talking about when it comes to the sacraments is very different than the mystery that we are talking about when it comes to detective books and shows.  The mystery of God isn’t a puzzle to be solved.  There usually aren’t nice tidy endings.  The mystery of God is more mysterious than puzzling.  It is a mystery to be pondered rather than a mystery to be solved.

Thinking back to my questioners last summer, it felt a little bit like a Nicodemus moment.  Nicodemus was a religious leader from the denomination of the Pharisees.  The Pharisees had a very logical approach to their faith, where everyone could have access to God through following the laws of the Torah.   But there was something about Jesus that seemed to intrigue Nicodemus, that drew him to come to Jesus by night.  We don’t get to see his motivations, but I wonder if something had disrupted his faith, that had him questioning what he thought that he knew.

But Jesus’s answers only led to further confusion.  Jesus talks about being born anew, born from above.  Nicodemus tries to picture someone crawling back into their mother’s womb to be born again.  “I don’t understand.  I don’t get it.”  Jesus talks about the Spirit-Wind, how she blows where she chooses, and how we must be born of the spirit.  Nicodemus asks how can this be.  “I don’t understand.  I don’t get it.”

And this is the last that we hear from Nicodemus in this chapter.  Jesus keeps on talking, but Nicodemus… he just sort of fades away, back out into the night.  He came to Jesus seeking clarity, but leaves with even more questions than he came with.

But I wonder if this is how it is with God.  That the more that we think we understand God, the further we are from God.  That God is Holy Mystery, to be contemplated, to be pondered, rather than understood.

As we hunger for God, we also hunger for mystery, we hunger for something that is beyond our ability to comprehend.  We hunger for a love that is so deep, so broad, so un-understandable, so all-encompassing that, like Nicodemus, we are shaken loose from all that we thought that we knew.

And in our hunger… in that mystery… God is there.

 

“Look Up for Faith, Hope, and Love”
Edie Mae Herrel
Used with Permission

No comments:

Post a Comment