27 July 2025

"Magic, or Idol, or Sign?" (sermon)

Two Rivers Pastoral Charge
Sunday July 27, 2025
Scripture:  Numbers 21:4-9


So in this year’s summer sermon series of “Wait?! What?! That’s in the bible???” when we’re looking at some of the lesser-known, quirkier stories in the bible, this week’s story falls under the category of just plain weird.

Unlike some of the other stories we’re going to be reading this summer, this story from the book of Numbers is actually found in the lectionary that we follow.  In chapter 3 of John’s gospel, Jesus refers to Moses lifting up the bronze serpent, and so on the 4th Sunday in Lent in year B, when we read chapter 3 of John’s gospel, this story is paired with it as the Old Testament reading.  But when I was reading and listening to some different commentaries on this reading, all of the commentators said some form of, “But none of you are going to actually be preaching on this story from Numbers, because it’s paired with the much more important, ‘For God so loved the world that he gave his only son’ reading.”

So this week is a bit of me pushing back on those commentators, and I am actually preaching on the story of the snakes in Numbers.

Like I said, it’s a weird story.  When I read it, two big questions or concerns jump off the page at me.  Number 1:  Surely God, a God who is love, didn’t actually send a bunch of venomous snakes to kill the people.  And Number 2:  What’s with healing people by having them look at a bronze snake on a pole?  This is sounding almost like magic or idolatry, and it wasn’t too long ago on their journey through the wilderness that the people got in a lot of trouble for worshipping a golden calf.

So those are my two concerns, and hopefully by the end of today I’ll have come up with some sort of satisfactory answer to both of them!

This story takes place in the middle of the Sinai wilderness.  If you remember, the Ancient Israelite people had been slaves in Egypt; Moses went to the Pharoah and demanded, “Let my people go!”; eventually the people were able to escape and Moses parted the waters of the Red Sea so that the people could cross over to safety; and then they spent 40 years wandering through the desert wilderness before they would be able to cross over the Jordan River into the land that had been promised to them and to their ancestors.

We don’t have an explicit time stamp on this story that we heard today, but it’s fair to say that they are getting close to the end of their 40 years of wandering in the wilderness.  They are still on the move, but in just a couple more chapters, Moses is going to climb to the top of a hill and he will be able to see the promised land.  Then Moses is going to spend almost all of the book of Deuteronomy summarizing the journey so far and repeating God’s law to the people, then Moses is going to die and Joshua will lead the people across the Jordan River.

So from our perspective, because we can read ahead, we know that the journey of the Ancient Israelites is almost over.  We know that it is not long before they will be crossing into a land flowing with milk and honey.  But from their perspective, they would have had no idea how close to the end they were.  From their perspective, they have been traveling through a desert wilderness for 40 years, and they have no way of knowing that the journey isn’t going to last another 40 years.

But their complaining has been almost continual, and poor Moses (and poor God) have been listening to their continual grumbling for almost 40 years now.  Right away – as soon as they had crossed the Red Sea to leave Egypt, and as soon as they had sung a song of praise to God for delivering them from slavery – they had barely had time to put their drums and their stringed instruments away when the complaints began.  Why have you brought us out here into the desert to die?  Why can’t we go back to be slaves in Egypt again, because even though we were slaves, at least we had cucumbers and melons to eat, and fresh water to drink?

If you read through Exodus and Leviticus and Numbers, it is a continual litany of complaint.  The people complain to Moses, Moses passes on their complaint to God, and God responds.  God provides manna for them to eat.  God tells Moses to strike a rock with his staff and fresh water flows from it.  God causes flocks of quail to land on their campsite so they can have fresh meat.

And still the people complain.  40 years later and we hear them still grumbling:  “Why have you brought us up out of Egypt to die in the wilderness?  For there is no food and no water, and we detest this miserable food that we do have.”

And then a… I don’t know the right word for a collective of snakes… a herd of snakes?  a flock of snakes?  appears, and bite the people, and the people start dying.

Which brings me to the first of my questions.  Do I believe that God actually sent the snakes to kill the people?  To that, I have to say no.  I don’t think that a loving God, who has been caring for the people through 40 years of desert wandering, would all of a sudden send something to kill them.  If you read the passage carefully, we don’t have God telling Moses, “Let me send a bunch of venomous snakes.”  Instead, we have the narrator’s observation – then the Lord sent poisonous serpents among the people.

If we consider that the people had been complaining to God and blaming God for the hardships that they had been facing in the desert, when a bunch of deadly animals show up, it makes sense that they would continue to blame God.  And so I see the snakes coming from God as the people’s interpretation of what is happening rather than what God is actually doing.

Because isn’t it a temptation that most of us face, that when something bad happens in our lives, we want to blame God?  God – why did you take my loved one from me?  Why didn’t you stop that fire from destroying my house? Why didn’t you (insert complaint here)?

In the story we read today, we hear from God for the first time when God gives Moses instructions for how to cure the people – make a bronze snake, and put it on a pole, and anyone who looks at the snake will live.  Even if God didn’t send the danger, God offers a path to safety.  Bad things happen in our lives – everything doesn’t always happen for a reason, sometimes stuff just happens – but God is always there to accompany us through the bad things.

But what’s with the cure that God offers?  Instead of herding the snakes out of the camp, instead of telling Moses to strike the rock with his staff so that anti-venom will pour out of it, instead God instructs Moses to cast a bronze snake, and raise it up on a pole above the people, and when the people look at the snake they will recover.  Really?  Just looking at a bronze snake will cure snakebites?  First of all, this is bizarre; second of all, it smacks of woo-woo magic rather than of God; and third of all, how is looking at a bronze snake different than worshipping a golden calf?

I think what is important here is intent.  The bronze snake was a sign.  The people weren’t supposed to see the snake and worship it – they were supposed to look at the snake and then look past the snake to see God’s presence.  The bronze snake is a sign, pointing towards God.

Because I don’t think that the thing that the Ancient Israelites needed to be cured from was snakebite, because that wasn’t what was really ailing them.  The thing that they needed to be cured from was forgetting about God.  And by looking at a bronze snake, they could be reminded that God was still with them, guiding them, protecting them, and feeding them.  The cure wasn’t about the snake itself, it was about what the snake pointed to.  And just like we don’t worship our bibles or our crosses or our candles, they can all help us to remember that God is with us.  Always and forever.

Last Tuesday at our movie night, we watched the animated movie Flow, which begins when a little grey cat has its life turned upside down when a sudden flood takes away its home and familiar routines.  The cat can never go back to the way that things were – it can only move forward.  Even at the end of the movie, the cat hasn’t returned to its old home – it has created a new home and a new chosen family instead.  The Ancient Israelite people can never go back to the way that things were – they can only go forward, trusting that something new and something good awaits them at the end of their journey.

And we too can’t go back in time – we can’t go back to whatever golden age we might hold in our imaginations.  But we can trust that, even when it feels like we are wandering through the wilderness, God is still with us, and that the Promised Land that lies ahead of us, in whatever form that promised land might take, is miles better than all of the cucumbers and melons that the Egypt of our imagination might hold.  And if we forget that God is with us, well, maybe we won’t want a bronze snake on a pole, but we can use the things we need to use to remind us of God’s presence – gathering together to worship, prayer, singing, candles, crosses, incense.

We can never go back to the way that things were, but the future ahead of us is going to be even better than what we have left behind, knowing that God is with us on the journey, and God will be with us at the destination.  Amen

 

 

I promised that I wouldn’t bring any snakes

(real or toy)

to church this week.

I hope that you will forgive me for this photograph

of a sculpture of the Bronze Serpent,

made by Giovanni Fantoni and found outside

the Memorial Church of Moses on Mount Nebo, Jordan.

Image used with permission.

No comments:

Post a Comment